Cooperstown Catering

How Our Catering Process Works

Planning an event in Cooperstown? Stagecoach Coffee makes catering simple with a four-step process.
Because we tailor every order to your event, we ask for as much advance notice as possible.

Questions? Call 607-547-6229 or email coffee@stagecoachcoffeeroasters.com

1.

Tell us the number of people.

2.

Choose your food selection from one of our our delicious options or create your own!

3.

Choose your beverage options.

4.

Pickup or delivery

Catering Menu

All food orders include disposable plates, napkins and utensils.
All drink orders includes cups, lids, cream, sugar, napkins and stirrers. Delivery available for an additional fee.
Please tell us if you have specific dietary restrictions.

Breakfast Catering

Because mornings move fast, we make it easy to feed a group. In addition, everything below can be mixed and matched to fit your event. Whether you’re feeding six or sixty, we can help you build the right order.

Dozen Bagel Box

Plain, whole wheat, sesame, cinnamon raisin, onion, everything$19.00
With plain cream cheese$28.50
With chive & onion or veggie cream cheese$32.50
Dozen Pastry Box
$48.50
Pastry choice: Cinnamon rolls, croissant (butter, chocolate, and almond), apple turnover, blueberry scones, multigrain berry bar
Muffin choice: Blueberry, cranberry nut, raisin bran, chocolate chip
Dozen Donuts
$16.50
Plain, powdered sugar, cinnamon sugar or espresso glazed
Chobani Vanilla Yogurt
Serves 10
With homemade granola or fruit$49.99
With fruit & granola$69.99
Heidelberg French Toast Bread Pudding
$70.00
With Mill Hollow Farm Maple Syrup
Serves 10
Lox n’ Bagel
$160.00
Onion, capers, cream cheese, tomatoes, cucumber, assorted bagels, lox and sliced lemons
Serves 10
Veggie Breakfast Pizza
$67.50
Puff pastry, eggs, NYS cheddar and veggies
Serves 10
Meat Breakfast Pizza
$85.00
Puff pastry, eggs, NYS cheddar, Boar’s Head ham and Gaia’s Breath Farm pork breakfast sausage
Serves 10

Lunch Catering

Since every platter serves 10, they’re built for meetings and gatherings alike. All platters also come with chips or a garden salad with balsamic vinaigrette. Either way, your group gets a full meal, not just a sandwich.

Deli Sandwiches
$135.00
Boar’s Head ham and turkey, tuna, pastrami, curried chicken salad or hummus served on Heidelberg French peasant bread or wheat wraps. Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, mayonnaise, and honey mustard
Deluxe Deli Sandwiches
$155.00
Turkey club, wrap the garden, vegan tofu wrap, classic ham with Swiss, curried chicken salad and classic turkey with basil aioli
Boar’s Head ham and turkey, tuna, pastrami, curried chicken salad or hummus served on Heidelberg French peasant bread or wheat wraps. In addition, each sandwich comes dressed with lettuce, tomato, cucumber, mayonnaise, and honey mustard.
Boxed Lunch $18.50 per person
Boar’s Head ham and turkey, tuna, pastrami, curried chicken salad or hummus served on Heidelberg French peasant bread or wheat wraps. Lettuce, tomato, cucumber, mayonnaise, and honey mustard packets
Includes sandwich, banana, cookie, chips & bottled water

Beverage Catering

Whether you need coffee for eight or a hundred, we have a size to match. Tea, flavored and regional coffee are all available, and every order includes cups, cream, sugar, and stirrers. That way, you don’t need to bring anything extra.

Box o’ Joe
$24.99
Serves 8
Press Pot
$24.99
Serves 10
Cambro
$89.99
Serves 48
Hot Chocolate Cambro
$115.99
Serves 48
Press Pot Hot Chocolate
$34.99

 

Dessert Platter

Since everyone’s sweet tooth is different, you can customize a dessert platter from any of our options below. For example, mix a few classic cookies with a gluten-free option so every guest has something to enjoy.

Cookies $1.95 each
Loaded oatmeal
Peanut butter monster
Vegan chocolate chip
Chocolate chip
Gluten-Free Cookies $2.25 each
Double chocolate-walnut
Peanut butter
Coconut macaroon
Chocolate chip
Oatmeal raisin
Breads
Banana, banana-chocolate chip, carrot cake, lemon poppy$3.25 each
Gluten-free and vegan options available$3.75 each
Because we bake in-house, flavors vary by season, so ask your barista what’s fresh that week.

Explore Cooperstown Before or After Your Event

Cooperstown is easy to explore. In fact, most attractions sit within a 10-minute walk of our shop, about the time it takes to enjoy one medium cappuccino. For history fans, a stroll down Pioneer Street leads to Lake Otsego, the real-life setting for James Fenimore Cooper’s The Leatherstocking Tales. Meanwhile, baseball lovers can visit the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum, and golfers can play a round at the 18-hole Leatherstocking Golf Course.

For a deeper look at local history, the Farmers’ Museum recreates a working 19th-century farm village. Nearby, the Fenimore Art Museum hosts world-class exhibits. In summer, visitors can swim in Lake Otsego or simply wander the historic village. When winter arrives, popular activities include ice fishing, Nordic skiing, ice skating, and snowshoeing.